Last Defense of Hoth - Question sur l'interrupt

Caal a écrit:Mais je pense que tu ne peux pas utiliser les 2 sur la même carte, a cause du "instead".
Je m'explique.
Une fois que le 1er a été résolu, la condition de déclenchement du 2ème n'est plus la, puisque le 1er l'a annulé (instead).
Pour moi il faut donc attendre que l'adversaire passe ou joue une carte pour pouvoir utiliser le 2ème.

Caal a écrit:PAR CONTRE, tu dois pouvoir interrompre le 1er avec le 2ème... Tu regardes ta carte, et tu vas la mettre dans le stack, mais a la place (instead) tu utilises le 2ème, tu regardes une nouvelle carte sur le dessus de ton deck, et tu la met a la place de la 1ère!! Ça ne fera toujours qu'une carte mise dans le edge stack.

Par contre, que ferait on de la 1ère? Discard? Reposez sur le deck?...

Skychapon a écrit:Hi,

We have a question about the Interrupt effect of the objective Last Defense of Hoth :

While this objective is undamaged, it gains: "Interrupt: When you would place a card into an edge stack, you may instead look at the top card of your deck and place it facedown in your edgestack. (Limit once per edge battle.)"

Ih I read corretly the FAQ :

The active player always has the first opportunity to use an ability that interrupts a given triggering condition, followed by his opponent, after which the active player may use another interrupt, and so forth. Interrupt opportunities for that triggering condition pass back and forth between players in this manner until both players have passed consecutively.
Once the opportunity to interrupt a triggering condition has been passed, that condition itself resolves (if it has not been canceled), and further interrupts to that specific triggering condition may not be used.

So I understand that, when a triggering effect, I can play any number of Interrupt triggered by a trigerring condition.

In fact, if I have 2 Last Battle of Hoth in play and start an edge battle, I can use the both objectives' interrupt at the same time, placing 2 cards in the edge instead of one. Here the time line of the case :

1. Each player have declared attacking and defending units, the edge battle start.
2. I attack, so I have the first opportunity to place a card in the edge battle. I use the interrupt of my first Last Defense of Hoth instead. My opponent didn't cancel this effect, so I resolve it and place the first card of my deck in my edge stack.
3. My opponent can trigger another interrupt with the same triggering condition of Last Defense of Hoth or pass. He decide to pass.
4. The triggering condition is still applied, so I can use the interrupt of my second Last Defense of Hoth. My opponent didn't cancel this effect, so I resolve it and place the first card of my deck in my edge stack.
5. We both pass.

At the end of this, I had put 2 cards in my edge stack instead of 1. It is correct? Or the point 4. is wrong because I have already place a card in my edge stack at point 2. and the triggering condition of point 2. is finished/canceled by resolving the first interrupt?

I need some clarification on this point, thanks in advance!

Nate French a écrit:As Last Battle of Hoth is a replacement effect (as indicated by the word "instead,"), the successful resolution of the first "Last Battle" card changes the triggering condition from "would place a card into an edge stack" into "instead look at the top card of your deck and place it facedown into your edgestack." At which point, you could still trigger the other interrupt (because you're still about to place a card into an edge stack), but it also is a replacement effect, so the second effect would now replace "look at the top card of your deck and place it facedown into your edge stack" with "look at the top card of your deck and place it facedown into your edge stack." And since you haven't done anything with the old top card of your deck yet, you would end up looking at the same card and then placing it in your edge stack.

Nate French
Senior LCG Designer
Fantasy Flight Games

Zanka a écrit:Et donc la top card revient sur le haut du deck c'est ça ?